Cape May Holiday Rentals

Thanksgiving in Historic Cape May

A Coastal Victorian Holiday

Gather the entire family under one roof by renting a classic Victorian home or beachfront cottage, where wraparound porches and spacious living rooms give everyone space to unwind together.  Skip the kitchen prep and cleanup this Thanksgiving with reservations at legendary local favorites like The Washington Inn, The Ebbitt Room, or Peter Shields Inn,  where multi-course holiday menus showcase coastal farm-to-table classics and fresh local seafood.

When Black Friday arrives, trade mall madness for a relaxed morning strolling the pedestrian-only Washington Street Mall. Discover one-of-a-kind holiday gifts at independent boutiques like Whale's Tale,  Across the Way, and Cape May Peanut Butter Co., alongside local art galleries and specialty jewelers.

Enjoy the season and book your holiday rental early for December to experience Cape May's storybook Christmas season. From the twinkling grounds of the Emlen Physick Estate and festive trolley rides to the historic Candlelight House Tours, winter at the coast brings a timeless holiday magic you will want to make an annual family tradition.

Washington Street Mall Holiday Shopping

BLACK FRIDAY Deals On Cape May, NJ. 

Skip the crowded shopping malls for the open-air Washington Street Mall. Stroll brick pathways lined with independent boutiques, local artisan craft shops, estate jewelers, and specialty confectioneries, where personalized service and unique seaside gifts replace chain store chaos. 

Christmas Candlelight House Tours

CHRISTMAS ON The Coast in CAPE MAY, NJ. 

Celebrated as one of America's best seaside holiday towns, Cape May transforms into a Dickensian winter wonderland throughout December. Enjoy historic Christmas Candlelight House Tours, horse-drawn carriage rides, the Emlen Physick Estate light displays, and festive carolers.

Plan Your Holiday Shopping

Shop Small, Give Back & Dine Local in Cape May

Skip the big box crowds this Black Friday and experience Cape May's magical winter escape. Every boutique gift, sweet treat, and cozy meal keeps your holiday dollars right here in the community you love.

Boutique Shopping

Washington Street Mall

Stroll our twinkling open-air pedestrian mall featured in our Cape May winter shopping guide. Support dozens of independent local merchants while finding one-of-a-kind holiday gifts.

Fashion & Gifts

Victorious of Cape May

Discover curated fashion, timeless jewelry, and distinctive gifts at this beloved local boutique. Shopping small here invests directly in the independent shops that give our Victorian town its charm.

Sweet Traditions

The Original Fudge Kitchen®

Sweeten your holiday stockings with creamy, hand-whipped fudge made right at the shore. Supporting this iconic Cape May staple keeps a cherished local tradition thriving.

Historic Dining

Elaine's Cape May

Pick up a gift card or enjoy a festive dinner at this historic boutique hotel and restaurant. Dining local this holiday weekend directly supports our year-round hospitality staff.

Coastal Seafood

Oyster Bay Bar & Restaurant

Unwind after your Black Friday shopping with fresh local seafood and warm hospitality. Treating friends and family to a night out here gives back to the community you love.

Italian Kitchen

Andrea Trattoria Italiana

Share authentic Italian comfort food with loved ones after a busy day of supporting small businesses. Every table filled helps sustain the independent restaurateurs who enrich our town.

French Bistro

Maison Bleue Bistro

Experience charming French cuisine crafted with passion right in the heart of town. Dining at independent bistros is one of the most rewarding ways to show love for Cape May.

Bath & Body

Shore Soaps

Treat everyone on your list to handcrafted, coastal-inspired bath and body goods. Shopping here keeps your holiday dollars local while supporting small-batch artisans in our community.

Gourmet Pantry

Cape May Olive Oil Co.

Delight the foodies on your list with gourmet olive oils and aged balsamic vinegars. Choosing this neighborhood specialty shop means giving back to the local flavor of Cape May.


Local Artisans & Café

West End Garage + Beach Plum Café

Browse over 60 local artisans, makers, and vintage curators, then refuel at the café. It is the ultimate one-stop destination to uplift dozens of Cape May creatives in a single visit.

Brunch & Cocktails

The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar

Fuel up for boutique hopping at The Carroll Villa Hotel's iconic eatery. Every brunch, cocktail, and gift certificate bought here reinvests in a cornerstone of Cape May culture.

Shore Gathering Spot

Carney's

Gather with friends for casual coastal fare and live entertainment after hitting the local shops. Spending your holiday weekend at neighborhood favorites keeps our shore community strong.


Handmade Pasta

Iccara Italian Bistro

Make your Black Friday evening memorable with handmade pasta and warm, personal service. Choosing local dining over national chains keeps resources circulating right here in town.

Neighborhood Pub

The Cricket Club Bar & Restaurant

Wrap up your Black Friday adventure with great food, drinks, and neighborhood camaraderie. Every visit supports the local owners and staff who make Cape May feel like home.

Cape May Apparel

Cape Mayniac

Give the gift of shore pride with apparel and accessories designed for true Cape May lovers. Every Black Friday purchase directly supports a beloved hometown business.

Specialty Shops

Carpenters Square Mall

Explore a charming collection of specialty shops and local vendors under one roof. Keep your Black Friday spending close to home and help our small business community thrive.

Neighborhood Café

Louisa's Cafe

Take a break from your Black Friday errands at this beloved local gem. Grabbing a fresh, locally sourced meal here is a delicious way to support the hospitality that makes Cape May special.


Fine Dining

Tisha's Cape May

Celebrate the start of the holiday season right on the Washington Street Mall. Supporting locally owned restaurants ensures our vibrant culinary scene flourishes all year long.


Oceanfront Dining

Harry's of Cape May

Highlighted in our Holiday Dining & Winter Escape Guide, Harry's offers oceanfront views and hearty fare plus gift cards that make wonderful stocking stuffers.


Fireside Landmark

The Washington Inn & Wine Bar

Named one of our top spots for cozy dining & fireside eats, a dinner or gift card here honors decades of local tradition and community spirit.

Make a Festive Weekend Out of Your Shopping Trip

Pair your Black Friday boutique tour with Yuletide house tours, trolley rides, and tree lightings on our Cape May Event Calendar or read our full guide on How to Spend Christmas in Cape May. Ready to stay close to the shops? Browse our Cape May Holiday Rentals today.


Cape May offers festive holiday experiences focused on Victorian history, charming tours, and seasonal entertainment. Visitors can explore decorated historic properties through guided experiences like the Evening Yuletide House Tour and the self-guided Lamplighter Christmas Tour, which both include the Carroll Gallery's model trains and giant tree exhibit. Guests can also enjoy town light displays on the popular open-air Holiday Lights Trolley Ride or take in a performance of the one-man show One Christmas Carol at Cape May Stage.

Visiting Cape May for Thanksgiving offers a peaceful getaway highlighted by cheaper vacation rental rates, flexible short stays, free street parking, and far smaller crowds than the summer peak. Enjoy festive holiday buffets and multi-course meals featuring traditional fixings alongside fresh seafood at destinations like Congress Hall, Ocean 7, and Union Park Dining Room. The holiday weekend also provides a relaxed shopping experience, allowing visitors to score unique gifts and seasonal deals along the Washington Street Mall during Black Friday and Small Business Saturday.

Follow Us